top of page

Citizens Oppose Flock Cameras by Wide 4-to-1 Margin at Shasta County Board Meeting; Sheriff Johnson Gives Misleading Presentation on the Cost of the System.

6 minutes ago
5 min read

Shasta County — November 17, 2026


The Shasta County Board of Supervisors heard extensive public comment and a presentation from the Sheriff’s Office on the automatic license plate reader (ALPR) cameras installed last year. The system was approved on the consent calendar on November 6, 2025, without discussion. Since then, concerns have grown about the collection and potential misuse of the data.


Four of the five supervisors attended. District 2 Supervisor Allen Long was absent. Supervisor Kevin Crye noted that Long’s conflicting meeting could have been rescheduled. Also present were Supervisors Corkey Harmon, Matt Plummer, and Board Chair Chris Kelstrom.


Sheriff Michael Johnson and Lieutenant Kody Bodner presented to a packed chamber. Before the meeting, residents protested outside with signs and black clothing, some bearing the slogan “Flock Off.” Johnson said he did not intend to debate the constitutionality of the cameras, stating that courts will decide that issue. He acknowledged surveillance concerns and said he is willing to make policy changes to “tighten things up.”


The cameras were funded with money from the PG&E Zogg Fire settlement. The five-year contract, valued at approximately $550,849, can be terminated early with 30 days’ notice. The Board cannot force the Sheriff’s Office to discontinue use before the end of the current fiscal year on June 30, 2027. The Board controls the budget and could choose not to fund the system in the next budget cycle. Supervisor Crye noted that a stipulation in Case No. 23CV-0202363 directed the Sheriff’s Office to use roughly $600,000 it received specifically for the Flock Safety LPR system rather than previously identified Toll System Data Link units. Judge Boeckman signed the order, and District Attorney Stephanie Bridgett presented it on behalf of the People of the State of California v. Pacific Gas and Electric Company, supported by a declaration from Undersheriff Gene Randall. The specificity of the stipulation raised questions about why a particular technology and vendor were designated, with some suggesting the system could aid arson investigations.


The presentation stated there are 26 cameras in Shasta County. Two of the cameras are owned by the City of Shasta Lake. Sheriff Johnson stated that each camera costs about $3,000 plus a $14,000 setup fee. Shasta Unfiltered reviewed the contract, which appeared in the November 6, 2025, agenda packet, and found that each camera cost $622.05 and 24 cameras came to $14,929.20. Sheriff Johnson stated, "The initial cost that we spent was $550,849." This is not what the contract shows, as the initial cost for year 1 was $122,113.20. Johnson went on to state, "There was $49,150 left over to pay for maintenance and/or replacement of damaged equipment." This misleads the public because the contract shows annual recurring costs for use of the Flock Safety Platform as $107,184.00 per year. The four years remaining on the contract come to $428,736. The $49,150 remaining is from the Zogg Fire Settlement amount of $600,000, not from the Flock camera contract.


(See Above) Sheriff Johnson's misleading slide presentation
(See Above) Sheriff Johnson's misleading slide presentation
Actual Flock contract terms: Note that the Year 1 subtotal spent was $122,113.20, and the annual recurring amount is $107,184.00.  The initial fee for each camera was $622.05.   Flock owns the cameras, not the County.
Actual Flock contract terms: Note that the Year 1 subtotal spent was $122,113.20, and the annual recurring amount is $107,184.00. The initial fee for each camera was $622.05. Flock owns the cameras, not the County.


The cameras capture license plates, location, and vehicle make and color on public roads. Data is checked against National Crime Information Center hot lists and, if a match occurs, is sent to officers in the field. The system is used for stolen vehicles, Amber Alerts, Silver Alerts, and investigative leads. It does not use facial recognition, capture names, dates of birth, addresses, or driver identities, and, according to Sheriff Johnson, does not monitor speed or issue citations.


Officials compared the technology to toll, FasTrak, red-light, and parking cameras. Lieutenant Bodner cited the “plain view” doctrine, stating there is no expectation of privacy on a public roadway. Use is governed by California Senate Bill 34 (ALPR law) and Senate Bill 54 (California Values Act). Searches are documented, and federal agencies are excluded. Data is retained for 30 days and then deleted, unless tied to an active case. Sheriff’s Office Policy 433 governs local use.


According to the presentation, the system has assisted in three homicide investigations, seven felony violent or sex crimes, 18 stolen vehicle recoveries, eight felony property crimes, 10 wanted persons cases, one carjacking, two arson investigations, and three missing persons cases.


The Sheriff’s Office offered several concessions:

  • Allied agencies would need to submit a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with a detailed reason and obtain commander approval for access.

  • Authorized agencies would be prohibited from sharing the information.

  • Any changes to Policy 433 would be provided to the Board for review before implementation.


Officials reported that 93 internal audits of system access and use over the past year found no concerns. Supervisor Plummer requested that future audits be conducted by an outside firm. Suggestions also included bi-weekly audits, a public transparency portal, and quarterly public reporting.


Forty-four members of the public spoke, each limited to two minutes. Opponents, ranging from school-age children to seniors, cited mass surveillance, warrantless searches, Fourth Amendment and California Constitution concerns, data security risks, limited transparency about Flock’s operations, and the possibility that future sheriffs might not exercise the same restraint. One speaker quoted Benjamin Franklin: “Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.”


Supporters said the cameras help solve crimes and deter criminal activity, while some favored continued use only with stronger restrictions. A few expressed concern that removing the cameras could attract criminals seeking areas with less surveillance.


Supervisor Crye said he regrets voting for the cameras on the consent calendar last year and is willing to admit when he is wrong. He noted an inaccuracy in the Sheriff’s presentation regarding Modoc County’s status with Flock. Crye also said he has lost some faith in government accountability during his four years on the Board, citing an instance in which he presented evidence of possible embezzlement to the District Attorney’s Office that he believed was not pursued.


Crye’s first motion, requesting that the Sheriff turn off the cameras, failed for lack of a second. His second motion directed staff to return with options for a legal path to place a charter amendment on the ballot that would prohibit use of the cameras in the county’s jurisdiction. Chair Kelstrom seconded the motion, which passed 4-0. Supervisor Plummer then questioned Sheriff Johnson and Lieutenant Bodner at length about current policy restrictions. Officials responded that the office follows California government codes and that access is limited to employees assisting with or investigating a crime, including trained non-sworn personnel. Plummer asked whether speeding alone triggers a search; the answer was that speeding alone does not, but reckless driving can. Plummer also asked about anonymized data retained by Flock; Bodner said he has a pending inquiry with the company on that point. Crye noted that the county’s Chief Technical Officer does not have access to the system. A case was mentioned in which individuals stole a Flock camera and accessed data by hacking the system.


Supervisor Harmon stated he didn't want to have to answer in the future to a citizen's complaint that his vote to end the use of Flock cameras resulted in the death of their loved one. He would prefer that the voters decide this difficult issue.


Plummer stated that constitutionality is a matter for the courts, which he expects will issue further rulings in the next one to two years. He supported an annual third-party audit, but his related motion received no second. Sheriff Johnson said he trusts the voters to decide the issue.


The Board passed two motions 4-0: one directing staff to bring back options for a possible charter amendment, and another requesting a future presentation from the Sheriff’s Office on recommended policy changes and updates.


Further coverage of other matters from the meeting will appear in a separate article.


To see the entire meeting video, go to:

MeasureB_v3.jpg
_Advertise Here_.jpg
Billboard with _Advertise Here_ text..jpg
bottom of page