Shasta Voters Spoke. Sacramento, the County, and the Court Said No
On November 9, 2026, Shasta County Superior Court Judge Benjamin L. Hanna permanently blocked Measure B, the charter amendment voters approved in the June primary by roughly 55–56 percent. Attorney General Rob Bonta and Secretary of State Shirley Weber sued to stop it. The County of Shasta took “no position.” The citizen proponents were represented by Alexander Haberbush of the Lex Rex Institute.
During the opening, Judge Hanna asked County Counsel Joseph Larmour whether the County wished to be heard. Larmour confirmed the County took no position. Hanna replied: “At least you’re consistent throughout these proceedings, Mr. Larmour. Appreciate that.”
Haberbush then argued that the tentative ruling went beyond what a motion for judgment on the pleadings allows. He contended the court misread the County of Sacramento case on charter-county authority, failed to address multiple pleaded defenses, and improperly rejected severance of non-conflicting provisions such as the paper-poll-book requirement that Shasta already uses. He asked the court to deny the motion, grant leave to amend, or limit any order to the specific clauses that actually conflict with state law.
After Haberbush finished, Deputy Attorney General Liam O’Connor responded briefly. Haberbush requested a rebuttal. Judge Hanna denied it and adopted the tentative ruling as written. The court held that Measure B’s key provisions are preempted by state law, that remaining provisions cannot be severed, and that a charter county may not enact election rules that conflict with statewide statutes. The judgment includes a writ, permanent injunction, and declaration structured so that any partial appellate win would return the case to the local court.
Haberbush said afterward: “Today’s ruling tells the voters of every charter county in California that they have no say over how their own elections are run. This ruling goes far further than any state law requires. It didn’t stop at the provisions the State said conflict with its statutes; it threw out even the requirement for paper poll books, which state law allows and Shasta County already uses. More than 55 percent of Shasta County voters made their decision. The County refused to defend it, and its lawyer told the court again this morning that the County takes ‘no position’ on this measure its citizens clearly wanted. Our clients do, and they’ll keep standing up for the voters. We’re reviewing every option, including an appeal.”
The real parties in interest added: “We are disappointed with the decision. The voices of the people of Shasta County should be listened to. We were not given a chance to argue the merits of the case. We feel this was a miscarriage of justice.”
The pattern is familiar. Citizens qualified an initiative. Voters approved it. The County declined to defend the result. State officials sued to nullify it. In February 2025, White House Deputy Chief of Staff Stephen Miller described a similar dynamic: “The threat to democracy, indeed the existential threat to democracy, is the unelected bureaucracy of lifetime tenured civil servants who believe they answer to no one… who believe they can set their own agenda no matter what Americans vote for.”
The parallel is not exact, but the structure is the same. Shasta voters used the initiative power reserved in the California Constitution. State officials and a non-defending county treated the result as optional. The court then struck the entire measure after a hearing in which the proponents were denied a rebuttal. Whether one supports Measure B or not, the sequence raises the question Miller posed: when voters act, and the apparatus of government treats the outcome as optional, who is actually exercising the democratic will?
Proponents are reviewing appeal options. For now, a majority of Shasta voters decided one way. State officials, the County, and the superior court decided another.







